# Tax Incidence Game for the Classroom — Who Really Pays?

Source: https://decka.dev/classroom/economics/tax-incidence-game

Your class becomes a market: buyers and sellers hold private cards and submit one set of orders. Then freeze those orders, tax the sellers, and move the same tax to buyers. Compare the price on the sign with what each side actually pays or keeps.

## What it teaches

Students distinguish the legal obligation to remit a tax from its economic burden. They trace the gap between buyer payment and seller receipt, see which trades disappear, and explain why moving the legal tax bill does not change those outcomes when the order book and per-trade tax stay fixed. The final question is what this controlled comparison cannot tell us about people who can bid again.

## A tax-incidence classroom game with a controlled comparison

A buyer’s card states what a crate is worth to them; a seller’s card states its cost. Each student submits one private bid or ask. When collection closes, the projector shows the anonymous curves made by those accepted orders. These are submitted prices, not a claim that everyone truthfully reported the value on their card.

The next two comparisons are deliberately hypothetical. The engine keeps the original order book fixed and computes one outcome with the per-trade tax collected from sellers, then another with it collected from buyers. The legal assignment changes the posted price, while the traded quantity, all-in buyer payment and net seller receipt agree across the two taxed cases whenever trade occurs. Students can compare both with the original no-tax market.

That is a narrower claim than saying a second classroom market would produce the same result. Students might change their bids, learn from the first round or react to how the tax is described. Use the held-fixed comparison to identify the accounting and incentive question before discussing those behavioral possibilities. This activity does not measure demand or supply elasticity or predict the incidence of a real tax.

Try the screen-and-phone preview with fictional classmates, who submit their orders through the same compiler and runtime as the lesson. You run the projector’s steps and play one student’s phone, entering that student’s own order. The classmates are not real students, and their orders are not presented as optimal strategies. Run it again with a different order to see how your trade and the curves change.

## Classroom debrief

Under each tax assignment, what do buyers pay in total and what do sellers keep?

Which numbers stay the same when the legal tax bill moves, and which posted price changes?

Which original trades disappear under the tax, if any?

If buyers and sellers could submit new orders after seeing the tax, what might change?

## Teaching tax incidence with this market

### Do students bid again when the tax changes?

No. They submit one original set of bids and asks. The two tax cases reuse those sealed orders and are labeled hypothetical. This keeps the legal assignment comparison controlled; it does not assume students would make the same choices in a new taxed round.

### Are the private value and cost cards shown on the projector?

No. Each person sees their own card and outcome on their device. After orders close, the projector shows anonymous bid and ask curves and market totals, not a name-by-name list of private cards or individual gains.

### Which course levels does this support?

For introductory economics, start once students can read supply and demand diagrams and focus on buyer payment versus seller receipt. In advanced undergraduate or MBA discussion, ask what changes when orders can respond to policy, and distinguish this fixed-book exercise from estimating incidence in a real market.

### Does this prove who bears every real-world tax?

No. It demonstrates two legal tax assignments using one held-fixed order book and a stated clearing rule. Real-world incidence requires assumptions and evidence about responses, market structure and the relevant time period; the classroom comparison is a starting point for that discussion.

## Run the lesson

Present the boards in PowerPoint, Google Slides and Decka. Students scan a QR code or open the session link to join from their phone browsers.
