# Peer Instruction in Physics — Vote, Argue, Vote Again, Live

Source: https://decka.dev/classroom/physics/peer-instruction

Every student votes alone on one collision question, then finds someone who chose differently and argues it out. The room votes again with the first tally taken down and no answer given in between, and only the second vote is marked on the projector.

## What it teaches

Students commit to an answer alone, test it against a classmate who disagrees, and meet Newton's third law in a collision: the lorry and the car push on each other exactly as hard, and equal force does not mean equal acceleration (a = F/m).

## What is peer instruction?

Peer instruction, the method Eric Mazur developed for introductory physics at Harvard, asks a conceptual question, collects each student's answer alone, has students convince a neighbour who answered differently, and asks again before anyone explains. Crouch and Mazur's report on its first ten years there is the standard reference.

Decka runs it on phones. The first tally goes up for the discussion and comes down before the second vote, nobody is told how any one person voted, and the answer appears only after both votes, marked on the second tally.

The question is Newton's third law in a collision: the lorry and the car push on each other exactly as hard. What differs is what that push does to each, because equal force on a much smaller mass gives a much larger acceleration.

## Classroom debrief

What changed between the votes, and which argument mattered?

If the forces are equal, why does the car come off worse?

Did anyone switch to a wrong answer? What made that argument convincing?

Which everyday words, such as “hit harder” or “stronger”, pulled people toward the lorry?

## Peer instruction questions, answered

### What is peer instruction?

A way of teaching in which students answer a conceptual question on their own, discuss it with someone who answered differently, and answer again before anyone explains it.

### When is the answer revealed?

Only after the second vote closes. The final board marks the correct answer on the second tally and leaves the first one unmarked.

### Do students see how others voted?

They see the room's tallies. Nobody is told how any one person voted.

### Does discussion always help?

No. Crouch and Mazur found it pays most when the first vote is split, and adds little when nearly everyone already has it right or too few do.

### How long does it take?

Two votes and a discussion; the saved default shows under the headline as "About N min", and every timer is a setting you control before you run it.

## Run the lesson

Present the boards in PowerPoint, Google Slides and Decka. Students scan a QR code or open the session link to join from their phone browsers.
